Lot 14

O'Connell Signed, Engraved, Gold Plated Winchester Model 1866

Previous image preload Next image preload
Back to catalog
Lot 14
image_0 image_1 image_2 image_3 image_4 image_5 image_6 image_7
O'Connell Signed, Engraved, Gold Plated Winchester Model 1866
O'Connell Signed, Engraved, Gold Plated Winchester Model 1866
image_0 image_1 image_2 image_3 image_4 image_5 image_6 image_7

O'Connell Signed, Engraved, Gold Plated Winchester Model 1866

Estimate: $140,000 - $225,000

Starting Bid: $120,000

(0 Bids)
by Rock Island Auction Company
June 27, 2026 5:00 PM CDT
Live Auction
3600 Harwood Road
Bedford, TX, US 76021

Extremely Rare 19th Century American Masterpiece, Thomas F. O'Connell Signed and Exhibition Grade Engraved, Gold Plated Winchester Model 1866 Lever Action Rifle with Framed O'Connell Engraving Print This is an extraordinary masterpiece of firearms artistry from one of the most talented, though rarely encountered, artisans of 19th century America: Thomas F. O'Connell. The second half of the 19th century is often referred to as a “golden age” of firearms engraving in America, and this particular rifle manufactured in 1870 certainly presents fantastic evidence in defense of that assessment. The period marked a transition point between the individually handcrafted firearms of earlier periods into the industrial era of mass production, with engraving and other embellishment becoming wildly popular among those who could afford it as a way to set their personal firearm apart from the hundreds of thousands of standard configurations that America’s factories were cranking out. In many ways, the second half of the 19th century in America can be seen as a period of contrast, where, on the one hand, the manufacturing might of the country was on full display, while on the other, were the elegant, bespoke masterpieces of some of America’s most talented artists. It is when these two are combined that we see pieces like this incredible rifle, which transcend both art and firearms collecting, becoming truly historic treasures of Americana. Though there were a number of highly skilled engravers in the United States during the 19th century, there are a handful of names that stand out amongst the field which truly defined the skill in America and helped to make the second half of the century the “golden age” of American firearms engraving. Many of these engravers were immigrants or the children of immigrants, reinforcing the “melting pot” strengths of this country and injecting various influences, particularly Germanic, into what would become the American style of firearms engraving. First and foremost, amongst these names is Gustave Young (1827-1895), who is often cited as the grand master among a field of extraordinary masters, having set the standard by which the others were measured and truly helped to define the American school of firearms engraving. Young primarily worked for Colt and later Smith & Wesson, taught the art to other masters of the era, and had two sons who also went on to be highly regarded in the craft. There was also Cuno Helfricht (1829-1921), who took over as Colt’s master engraver after Young’s departure to Smith & Wesson and engraved some of Colt’s most legendary pieces, particularly for the Philadelphia Centennial Exhibition in 1876, one of the most iconic celebrations of American art and industry. There was also the Ulrich family, with Conrad F. and John being two of the most prominent members. The two brothers initially trained under Young at Colt, carrying much of his influence into their work at both Winchester and Marlin, essentially defining the artistry of two of America’s most legendary brands. Finally, there was Louis D. Nimschke, a German immigrant who would go on to become one of the most talented firearms engravers of the period and arguably the most prolific, engraving an estimated 5,000 firearms from essentially all the country’s major manufacturers during his career. He is credited with creating a whole sub-style within the American school of engraving, which is often referred to as “New York style” engraving today, and his impact and influence on American firearms engraving during the period is enormous. It is a style that is magnificently illustrated on this extraordinary rifle, which was masterfully embellished by one of the lesser known and much more rarely encountered New York artisans of the period, Thomas F. O’Connell. Sadly, it appears that much information about Thomas F. O’Connell has been lost with time, probably, in part, due to his tragically short life. O’Connell was born in New York to Irish parents in 1851, which is confirmed by the 1880 Census which lists him as an engraver, his wife Sarah, and two young children Thomas and Ella, ages four and two. In Trow’s “New York City Directory, 1876-1877”, O’Connell is listed as an engraver at 50 Ann Street in Brooklyn, a location not too far from New York City Hall. Interestingly, that location is also only about a mile and a half away from 1 Essex Street, which was the address of Louis D. Nimschke’s shop from 1870 to 1891. It does not appear to be documented, but, given the similarities in the style of O’Connell’s engraving to the work of Nimschke, it is certainly possible that he apprenticed under the father of New York style engraving. There are few known examples of O’Connell’s engraving on firearms, but those that do exist all appear to bear his signature “T.F.O’C”, which has been previously misidentified as the marking of Thomas F. O’Connor, a prominent international salesman for the Winchester company. A few prints of engraving plates by O’Connell are also known, one of which is included with this rifle, indicating that firearms may not have been what he primarily engraved. The surviving examples of his work show exceptional talent with the quality of his work being every bit as fine as that of L. D. Nimschke. Another example of his work is pictured on p. 42 of “Winchester Engraving” by R.L. Wilson, where his signature is incorrectly identified as O’Connor as previously mentioned. That Winchester Model 1866 bearing serial number 21064 shows a very similar engraving pattern to this example, including the American eagle and shield on the left sideplate. This particular rifle is identified and pictured in the American Society of Arms Collectors Bulletin 108:13-19. This rifle and the rifle pictured in the book are quite possibly the only known Winchesters engraved by this talented artist, making his work far rarer than that of Nimschke. Unfortunately, O’Connell’s career as an engraver appears to have been cut short, though the cause is unknown, leaving examples of his work exceptionally scarce on today’s collector’s market. “The Brooklyn Daily Times” on 8 April 1882 shows an obituary for Thomas F. O’Connell, stating that he died on 6 April, leaving behind a wife and two small children, and noting that he was an engraver and “a young man of unusual promise”. Having been produced in 1870, this is a truly extraordinary example of Winchester’s legendary Model 1866 rifle, the model which laid the foundation for the company’s lever actions to go on and dominate the American long gun market for nearly a century and making Winchester one of America’s truly iconic brands. The Winchester '66 remains indelibly linked to the taming of the American frontier and remains a legendary piece of Americana in the eyes of modern collectors, continuing to be highly desirable in any configuration and essentially any condition. High condition examples such as this are extremely scarce, representing a window into the past of this country as truly historic time capsules. Then there is the engraving, which elevates this piece to among the elite of 19th century American arms collecting, as a true masterpiece of the famed New York school of engraving. The engraving itself encompasses essentially all of the receiver, elegantly encapsulating it in beautifully executed floral scrollwork on beaded backgrounds, showing many similarities and comparable skill to Nimschke’s scrollwork. O’Connell’s “T.F.O’C” signature is stamped on the bottom between the cartridge elevator and the lever. The beautiful scrollwork continues on the forearm cap and tang of the buttplate. The forward left and right portions of the frame feature dog’s heads worked into the scrollwork, and there are kidney shaped fan motifs on the top of the receiver ring and bottom of the cartridge elevator, all designs that are typical of both O’Connell and Nimschke’s work. The right sideplate features a blank inscription area within a decorated border. The left side plate features a magnificent, highly detailed, American bald eagle perched upon the shield from the Great Seal of the United States, with a stand of American flags in the background. Adding to its deluxe nature, the receiver, forearm cap, and buttplate on this rifle are all beautifully gold plated. The top barrel flat is marked with the standard two-line Winchester address and King’s patent marking. The serial number is marked on the lower tang just behind the trigger in block numerals. It is fitted with a front sight base with absent blade, a folding ladder rear sight, and sling swivels on the forearm cap and bottom of the stock. It is mounted with a very finely figured forearm and straight grip stock with a crescent buttplate. Included with the rifle is a rare and highly desirable framed print of Thomas F. O’Connell’s engraving which is titled “American Sports”. It shows various, highly detailed scenes of popular American sports including baseball at the top center, all surrounded by O’Connell’s beautiful scrollwork, and discreetly marked with his copyright at the bottom center. These pieces represent true treasures by one of the rarely encountered masters of America’s “golden age” of firearms engraving.

Manufacturer: Winchester

Model: 1866

BBL: 24 inch octagon

Stock: walnut

Gauge: 44 Henry RF

Finish: blue/gold

Serial Number44156

Class: Antique

  • Provenance: The Robert M. Lee Collection; The Nassab Collection
  • Condition: Exceptionally fine as a rare Thomas O'Connell signed masterpiece from America's "golden age" of firearms engraving, retaining 85% plus of the original blue finish on the barrel and 75% remaining on the magazine tube with the balance mostly grey patina and a few patches of light spotting. 97% of the bright, original nitre blue remains on the loading gate. It retains 95% of the bright gold plating with most of the loss contained to the forearm cap and buttplate. The engraving remains extremely crisp throughout. The forearm is fine with some scattered minor dings and scratches. The otherwise very fine buttstock has a professional period repair in the wrist and some light handling marks. Mechanically excellent. The framed print is excellent with only the slightest handling/storage evidence. This rifle is truly a treasure from the "golden age" of American firearms engraving, displaying the masterful work of one of the more talented and rarely encountered artists of the period, Thomas F. O'Connell. It could easily be the centerpiece of even the finest collections of 19th century high art American arms.

Accepted Forms of Payment:

American Express, Discover, MasterCard, Money Order / Cashiers Check, Personal Check, Visa, Wire Transfer

Shipping

Rock Island Auction will contact you shortly after the auction has completed. We will arrange for shipping and or pickup.

Rock Island Auction Company

You agree to pay a buyer's premium of 30% and any applicable taxes and shipping.

View full terms and conditions

Bid Increments
From: To: Increments:
$0 $199 $10
$200 $499 $25
$500 $999 $50
$1,000 $1,999 $100
$2,000 $4,999 $250
$5,000 $9,999 $500
$10,000 $19,999 $1,000
$20,000 $49,999 $2,500
$50,000 $99,999 $5,000
$100,000 $199,999 $10,000
$200,000 + $25,000